Initially, I avoided The Wire because I wondered if it was truly drama or just TV intent on scaring white folks into voting Republican. Three seasons ago, I gave in to the buzz, and The Wire drew me in. I'm not from Baltimore, and I have never been there, but The Wire felt a lot like watching my old 'hood disintegrate. Race and class were complicated by politics and corruption. Lines between good and evil were blurred by good intentions. Yes: I'd seen this before. I was pretty sure that it was just more media that took a decidedly bourgeois look at an inner city black America that can only be cured by education, public assistance programs or well-meaning white people. The Wire proved more complicated than that, but not by much.
The show never found a large audience, and I understand why. The script sounds like watching David Mamet shoot craps with Bonz Malone: fun for writers, readers and students of The Game. For the rest of the viewing public, it acted out a lot of what many believe they already know: Black America is a dark, dangerous place where Good Negroes and cops do the best they can to tame the Natives. The Wire's dominant narrative is driven by the worst kinds of people exploiting the worst imaginable circumstances in the worst possible way: this is a portrait of Bill Cosby's Black America. Not exactly a fresh take.
I'm not waiting on the Black Waltons or The Cosby Show 2.0, but it's frustrating that we can't get a black drama on television that doesn't involve drugs and crime. Italians probably feel the same way. I'm all for keeping it real, but the portrayals that the get the best notes always involve Blacks Behaving Badly. Some critics read alot of deep, sociological implications into the show. Not me. In the end, The Wire falls somewhere between Birth of A Nation and the Six O'clock news as urban propaganda: a unique compilation of white liberal science fiction and hip-hop gun porn.