The Root | TheRoot.com
Skip Navigation
Cancel

Jimi Izrael

Full Post
Posted Monday, February 25, 2008 2:23 PM

Duke Rape Scandal, Two Years Later

izraelj

On March 13, 2006 two young black women, professional strippers, were hired for a college party. Within a month, the nation was embroiled in the Duke Lacrosse Rape Scandal, where a number of white men were accused of raping one of the dancers. This was a made for media scandal, and black commentators from coast to coast were quick to call for the head of these young men. I was not among them. Early on, I said something vey impolite: that if you thought for a moment you would ever get any truth from a room full of privileged rich kids and two women whose job it was to lie, cheat and steal to separate men from their money, you were delusional. The scenario had all the markings of a "trick toss"—essentially a grab-n-dash—gone awry.  The young men weren't innocent—as it was clear that they'd had broken the school's honor code—but I was pretty sure they didn't rape that young lady. Long before the evidence presented itself, I basically told people how it was gonna go down. And, point for point, it came to pass.

The woman has fallen off the public stage, but we all know the names and faces of the accusers, and they have to live with that for the rest of their lives. Yes, we know they made racial insults and were generally ungentlemanly, but they weren't rapists. Rev. Al Sharpton, to his credit, never jumped into the lynch mob, so Whoopi misspoke when she said he owed the boys an apology. It's almost two years on and I'm still wondering who among the columnists, feminists, opportunists, activists and others will step forward and apologize to these boys. They were vilified for nothing, and their names and reputations were besmirched by a woman making false allegations.  Not just that, but by lying, the woman made it harder for real victims of rape to come forward. I predicted that we would never find out what happened that night, but we'd all feel a little greasier, no matter what. And I think I was right.

Don't the accused Duke Lacrosse Players have an apology coming? Why or why not?

Jimi Izrael is a writer and commentator living in Tallahassee, Florida.

You must be a registered user to comment.  Click here to register.  Already a user?  Click here to login.

Member Comments

Posted By: Dolphinfan65 (February 25, 2008 at 5:59 PM)

Yes, it's called a BIG PAY CHECK!!!


Posted By: tobaccoschild (February 25, 2008 at 7:20 PM)

Perhaps, but individuals (i.e. black and brown people) have their lives inconvenienced in this way all the time and seldom receive an apology and much less a paycheck.  I think what happened was unfortunate, but why should they be the face of the injustice of the justice system that we know has been perpetrating similar vile acts?  I'm sorry it was unfortunate, but these men can and will put their lives back together.


Posted By: homelandcolors (February 26, 2008 at 10:18 AM)

I just wish that some African American leaders had taken more advantage of the situation.  The Duke case was one that highlighted prosecutorial misconduct.  Many African American’s are the victim of rouge prosecutors and the Duke boys would have useful in selling the wider society on the need for justice system reform that would have benefited African American communities.  It is a lost opportunity.  


Posted By: ladybee21 (February 26, 2008 at 11:14 AM)

I guess their apology is coming in the form of lawsuits that demand millions from Duke and the city of Durham. The suits originate not just from the three who were arrested, but from the entire team. They have refused several million dollar settlements from the city's insurance policies, seeking instead to strip needed resources from our community.  Durham is a mostly black town that will suffer from their privilege.  So before you go feeling so terribly sorry, know that their well-connected lawyers and families will take their pound of flesh from the larger community that did nothing to them.


Posted By: macdw (February 26, 2008 at 2:16 PM)

You know, my grandma used to say that if you are somewhere you have no business being, doing things you have no business doing, then something bad is going to happen to you.  Those young men were not innocent.  They violated school rules and behaved in an inapproriate way.  Our society's willng dismissal of men and their poor behavior should be fodder for another discussion on another day.  I don't feel sorry for them.  They will be just fine.


Posted By: ken (February 26, 2008 at 3:47 PM)

The three accused lax players will be just fine; they have connections, a good education, and white skin to boot.  

The real victims are the women who really do get raped and now are more afraid than ever to come forward.  Imagine you're some poor freshman girl at Duke and a drunken meathead forces himself on you after you had a couple of beers, how do you work up the nerve to press charges?  The real victims are the women who have been raped and will get raped in the Durham area who, in addition to the trauma of being sexually assaulted, will make the awful decision to keep it to themselves for fear of being publicly humiliated in the court of public opinion.


Posted By: TripleJJJ (February 26, 2008 at 5:05 PM)

Being a long time Duke hater may be infulencing me slightly but those "kids" deserved to be expelled. I went to college and we all had a grand old time without ever employing strippers/hookers. With all those beautiful young women around who had time to look at skanky crakhead hookers? The poor little rich kids should be shamed and their parents should be ashamed. Of course they're not in the least. "Everyone knows my son's name now he'll never be able to get a job making a million a year!" I'd never seen the kids until their parents took them on national TV to complain.


Posted By: afrocine (March 4, 2008 at 10:35 AM)

I'm from Durham.  The three kids who were charged will be fine, riches await them. The other 38 are nasty little punks who terrorized campus and the city for years and are now trying to give Duke and Durham one last F/U!  The culture created by this team of scofflaws was legendary.  Neighbors and students alike were at their mercy.  Now they want a piece of the finacial pie so that they can put their lives back together?  Their lives were never, never, ever harmed in any way.

In 1979 a woman was murdered in Durham by a big black dude.  I was walking down the street and happened to fit the physical profile, the cops pulled took me in, threatened me and held me and others who looked like me until they determined that we were not the culprit.  I did not sue Durham, I had no grounds.  The police were investigating a crime, I resembled a suspect, they had probable cause.  They also had probable cause in the Duke LAX case.  This should not be actionable.  Finnerty, Evans and Seligman deserve our consideration, not everyone on the LAX roster does.


Posted By: pinhead (March 21, 2008 at 7:42 PM)

Amazingly enough, I don't remember the names of those young men, but I would recognize the name of the woman because misogynists screamed it on the street corners for an entire year.

Also, the number of reported rapes dropped dramatically in the year following the infamous Duke case, but the number of women going to Durham rape crisis centers increased.  That's because they figured no one would believe them after this mess.  You're not doing your sisters any favors by beating the "all women are lying whores" drum.  


Posted By: Amoxicillin 500 mg facts. (April 16, 2008 at 5:57 PM)

Amoxicillin rx655 syphilis. Amoxicillin. Amoxicillin expiry. Augmentin vs amoxicillin. Amoxicillin side effects. Amoxicillin order mexico mexican. Amoxicillin online homepage.