The Root | TheRoot.com
Skip Navigation
Cancel

Blog Title

Full Post
Posted Saturday, April 26, 2008 12:05 AM

San Francisco, Sean Bell, and Me

rebeccawalker

police 

 

So I'm sitting on the floor in the hallway of a friend's house in San Francisco's Noe Valley, en route to the UK. The sun is shining, the sky is blue, and I'm happy to be back in my city. The only thing is there's a swarm of police officers outside and they've got huge guns, the biggest I've ever seen, trained on the house next door.

At first I think it's a drug raid, but really have no idea. All I know is I was answering emails and heard people outside yelling. I walked to the window, pulled back the curtain and found myself looking at six or seven police officers in full gear, each with a semi-automatic weapon pointed at the window. I backed away slowly, afraid any sudden move could turn the guns my way. 

I heard the door to the flat at the back of the house open and ran to tell the woman who lives there with her husband and three-month old baby girl not to go outside. She wasn't fazed. It's a couple down the street, she said. A messed-up husband, messed-up wife, and messed-up teenage son. There's gang stuff that goes on, too, she said. But today it's probably the family.

I inched back to the window in time to hear a neighbor ask the police if they had finally found Bin Laden. Three white guys strolled down the street. Some guys with dreadlocks texted on their cells. A guy who looked Samoan took video with his phone. An African-American woman watched from her steps without so much as a flinch.

I felt I was in some kind of alternate universe. Was I watching successful community policing, or a troubling acceptance of a militarized environment? I mean really, was I the only one who wanted to go hide on the bathroom floor?

Sadly, perhaps unfairly, when I see police officers I usually think of Rodney King, Michael Steward, Amadou Diallo. I think about female inmates brutally raped by prison guards. I think about Michelle Obama telling CNN Barack could get shot going to the gas station.

I think about what I'm going to tell my son about the police when he's old enough for it to matter.

I will have to tell him the truth: he should expect and demand the police protect him.  He should know they may not. I will tell him the history of police brutality in our country, and of the increasingly likelihood of an even more militarized state. I will talk to him about countries where guns are illegal. He will have a passport.

I will do my best to preserve my son's sense of hope and wonderment about the world, his sense of safety. I will tell him he must always, always, obey the law. I will tell him there are and have always been lawyers who fight for those who have endured police brutality.

I will tell him he must be especially cautious of being in the wrong place at the wrong time; it can cost him his life. I will repeat this at different times in his life, moments when I think he may be able to hear it, and moments when I know he cannot. I will love him as hard and fiercely as I can so he will know the difference between healthy affection and dangerous liaisons.

I will teach him to step away from the window.

What do you think about when you see police officers, and what will you teach your kids?  

 


 


 




 

 

 
 

 

 

 
 

You must be a registered user to comment.  Click here to register.  Already a user?  Click here to login.

Member Comments

Posted By: mawonajj (April 26, 2008 at 4:56 AM)

Gurrl:

I was gonna rely on you and your kind to let us know what to do. What works? I haven't even had that discussion completely with my kids even though they know what's up coz so many of their relatives are caught up in the system. They've been unfairly scolded by folks outside and it's been a real struggle to protect them.

I look forward to you input and give us net guides or references if you know of any.

Best,


Posted By: mikez (April 27, 2008 at 9:31 AM)

always portraying the police as bad guys I see....when I see them i think of all the negative things that SOME OF THEM DID not all....PLZZZZZZZZZZZZ

quit sterotyping cause Im pretty sure if someone sterotyped you, you would be madder than hell...am I right

there is good and bad in all people and some just cant do any good and take it out on other people, and Gurrl tell your kids that cops are good guys not all of them but most are and they just want to earn your childs trust along with yours....if you let them grow up believing all cops are "the enemy" then they will end up just like your relatives...on the wrong side


Posted By: adpforjc (April 27, 2008 at 10:18 AM)

police and law enforcement is what america is all about.there are people in the world that care about no one but themselves.intent on harming others for their own twisted motive.here comes a young or old police officer with a wife and children at home.his life is in danger every day by people who see him as a threat to their selfish lifstyle of robbery murder anger and violence.and they will do anything to stop him.these officers are laying down their lives to protect you from what could be a horrible tragedy.they understand that at any moment they may lose their lives but are prodded on by a higher calling , a love for peace and freedom , and a love for people and justice.freedom does not mean we can do anything we want , it means as long as we live according to the laws and statutes of this nation we are free to pursue life and happiness


Posted By: growth12 (April 27, 2008 at 10:40 AM)

To the two posters who are defending the police: yes, we need them (I would prefer that they treated the black victims of crime in the same way they treat white victims, but that's perhaps too sci-fi). I live in the suburbs of Baltimore and I really feel for the police officers here. Having said that, there must be checks and balances within the police department, just as there are checks and balances in every industry. There must also be an acknowledgment that many police officers (including, and sometimes especially, black and Latino officers) bring internalized racism into the mix when they're policing neighborhoods where blacks and Latinos live. It is truly an outrage that the officers involved in Mr. Bell's case did not receive at least a warning, or diversity training, or something. That is what people are upset about. Rebecca Walker is right to be concerned about her son as he gets older. This society is very hostile toward black men (no matter how educated, accomplished, etc.) and has a history of being so. I wish some of us would read the history books and get a sense of why this is so. One of the first prisons was opened shortly after slavery was abolished. If that doesn't say something, nothing does. We, as a nation, need to think about what the criminalization of people of color and the poor has done for us--if anything, it's created more crime (sometimes on the part of officers, as in Bell's case) and more problems. Something's got to change with our justice sytem, because it's very, very flawed.


Posted By: jstafrn (April 27, 2008 at 9:20 PM)

When I see the police I watch them closely to determnine whether they're watching me or not.  When I see some of my "brothers" milling around the Richmond BART station I watch them to see if they're watching me.  Aint that a blip; it seems I'm afraid of being harmed in both cases.


Posted By: bylinediva (April 28, 2008 at 8:38 AM)

girl, come on, what alternate universe do you live in? the world is not all roses. don't you live in NYC? teach your son to avoid confrontations with police, period. that means outside of clubs, in the streets, wherever he might encounter them. if he does have a situation with them like a car stop, then he should know to show his hands,calm any passengers with him, so they don't do anything stupid and answer every question politely and succintly. that's how best to deal with police as a black man.


Posted By: rebeccawalker (April 29, 2008 at 4:58 AM)

I actually live in Hawaii which has its own problems, but fear of the police isn't one of them. It 's interesting though, that we moved to Hawaii because of our concerns about what is happening in American cities, and my return trips confirm the increase of violence. When I tell friends about what happened, they say this is becoming normal in SF. When I grew up here, trust me, this was not normal. I realize everyone can't up and move to Hawaii--though it is not the paradise most think it is and moving is easier than you think, but we all do need to be thinking more internationally. Part of any plan at this point must include the possible necessity of movement. Thanks for your survival kit of hands visible, respectful speech, and so on. The more ways we employ to prepare our children, the better. I like the idea of somehow building alliances with police officers, too. Figuring out how to forge more productive bonds, human to human. Perhaps officers can mentor young people in at-risk communities. Institutional, programmatic intervention is a start.


Posted By: growth12 (April 29, 2008 at 6:24 AM)

Rep. Bobby Scott has proposed legislation that we should all support (especially since Feinstein, etc., have proposed legislation that would incarcerate young people for perceived gang activity, even if that just means they are hanging together on a street corner). Spread the word:

H.R. 3846: The Youth Prison Reduction through Opportunities, Mentoring, Intervention, Support, and Education Act (Youth PROMISE Act)

Under the Youth PROMISE Act, communities facing the greatest youth gang and crime challenges will come together to develop a comprehensive plan for implementing evidence-based prevention and intervention strategies. These PROMISE Councils will include representatives from law enforcement, court services, schools, social service, health and mental health providers, and community-based organizations, including faith-based organizations, and the strategies articulated in the PROMISE Plan will be targeted at young people who are at-risk of becoming involved, or involved in, gangs or the criminal justice system to redirect them toward productive and law-abiding alternatives. The bill has 58 cosponsors and was the topic of a hearing on October 2, 2007. For more information about this legislation, please see Representative Scott’s website report on the Youth Promise Act.

To learn more, go to Scott's website: http://www.house.gov/scott/


Posted By: cancan (April 29, 2008 at 10:06 PM)

You have to prepare a black male child to know how to deal with the police and with his peers.  There was a black woman in NYC who wrote a Little Black Book some years ago after a similar killing that gave instructions for black boys to know how to act when stopped by the police, to get to know the name of their precinct captain, etc.  To keep them alive.

I have heard black pollicemen talk about how they get afraid when they're in civilian clothes and come into contact with police who don't know them.

And, my son has had to watch his back around his black male peers who don't know him.  Being a young male of color is fraut with possibilities of harm from those unknown and known to you, alike and unlike.  That's the reality!


Posted By: greenie227 (April 30, 2008 at 9:00 AM)

jstafrn, i think your comment saddened me the most. it's not just white police who may hold beliefs and power to harm young black men, it is young black men themselves and their peers who may hold beliefs and power to harm young black men. what is the answer? how do we stop this spiral? it's not just one side or the other cleaning up their act -- that leads to blame and name-calling and obfuscation. how do we come together to figure this out? how do find these young men opportunities without taking such opportunities from other young people? how do we grow this world and use the brainpower we all possess, instead of letting it rot on a corner, get shot and killed due to bias (and I'm guessing experience in similar situations by these cops, as well as well-founded assumptions about Sean Bell's companions)?


Posted By: ZZim (April 30, 2008 at 9:13 AM)

So... everybody but you was blase about the whole episode. You were hypervenitilating and panicking while everyone else calmly went about their business. Everyone but you. Fifty people saw the same thing and only you perceived yourself to be menaced and threatened.

How can all 49 of those other people be so out of touch? It boggles the mind. I hope you teach your child to be a grounded and as in touch with reality as you are. Those 49 other people will need some guidance. Someone who looks at the same scene and perceives it totally differently than they do. After all, who willl interpret what they see for them? Who will enlighten them? Who will explain to the other 49 people that this is NOT a humdrum event? This is terrifying! If only they had the eyes to see! And if they focused on the important and relevant aspects of police behavior, then they would understand what police are really all about - menace, danger, random brutality, hate, lusting after victims to rape and mutilate for pleasure. They're not all like that, but a large enough percentage of them are that we should feel terror at the sight of policemen. The other 49 people need to wake up and smell the brutality. Please teach your son that if he is ever lost at the Zoo or the mall that he should avoid anyone in uniform at all costs. If he sees a blue uniform, he should run and hide. After all, who knows what they'll do to him if they find him alone and unprotected? Surely their first impulse will be to harm him in some fashion?

After all,m what other possible reason could they have for taking a job that required the handling of firearms? The only purpose of firearms is to hurt and maim and to kill? So isn't it reasonable to assume that these men - they're almost all men - really and truly desire to harm people as frequently as popssible? And who better to harm than a lost little boy at the Zoo crying for his mother? Make sure he runs and hides and doesn't come out, no matter who he sees calling and looking for him. They might be plain-clothes "undercover" policemen adopting a disguise to get closer to their intended victim.

Like Sean Bell. That's why they were there at that club, dressed like civilians. They were looking for young Black men they could kill. They knew the criminal justice system would cover for them as the went about their boys-will-be-boys antics. They're probably in some police locker room right now getting high fives and hearing "Nice one, guys!"


Posted By: scribe02 (April 30, 2008 at 11:31 AM)

Having been a police officer, I had always tried to treeat those I came in com=ntact with equal respect.  But, I can say I didn't always get that in return.  Black and  White, it didn't seem to make much difference.  Most people have no idea what it's like to be on the oher side of that badge.  You make a mistake or give some one the benifit of the doubt (and be wrong) you don't go home that night and I have three kids.  Believe me I'm going home.  Yes, there are bad cops just like bad writers, bad doctors, bad politicians, bad preachers/preists, and the list goes on.  I know where you're coming from though, I've been stopped for dwb a few times myself.


Posted By: Hal in MS (April 30, 2008 at 4:40 PM)

My son is 13 going on "a pain in the ass." We've given him such a sheltered childhood, I worry if he'll have the survival skills needed when he gets "out there"..  We're always on him about losing his wallet he probably figures it's more about personal responsibilty, we know he can't afford to be out there without his drivers license (in the near future) in case he gets pulled over.  We know at some crucial time he'll be away from the cocoon and hve to fend for himself as a black male in an adverserial world...........

JOIN THE MOVEMENT TO REMOVE PAT BUCHANAN FROM MSNBC !!!!!!


Posted By: bylinediva (April 30, 2008 at 8:12 PM)

yes, you do live in an alternate universe rebecca! i know i sounded flippant maybe its because i live in a big northeastern city and my brother has had many brushes with the police. he's not a criminal but he does love to drive fast! fortunately they haven't been fatal, although he lives in a southern city where black police officers sued the police department for racism. i truly wish your worldview was more of the norm and you son never has to be put in that kind of defensive position. but if he is, forewarned is forearmed. sadly just about EVERY black man i know, regardless of dress, station in life, education, etc. has a story about dealing with the police.


Posted By: lovinme (April 30, 2008 at 8:53 PM)

I think police officers expected to much from a person with no outlet. these kids that are in ganges don't think they have a chance in life. We as people need to address the situation. Its always easier to point a finger and say he's just no good he will never be anything. i think we need to start helping people mentally and get to the core of the problem and show them that there is an alternative to life. Must of these kids grow up in a single parent home and their parent may have been brought up the same way. I noticed kids from that enviorment tend to be short handed as to there were two parents. I will teach my kids to love themselves before anything. and instill my blivesfes. At the end of the day u are going have to let go and let them be them its the circle of life


Posted By: Typhoon McGoon (May 1, 2008 at 3:09 PM)

>>I will have to tell him the truth: he should expect and demand the police protect him.

Slightly off topic, but protecting the public is not one of the functions of the police. I also used to believe this, until I survived a home invasion robbery, and smiling detective explained that it's up to each individual to protect himself. This is contrary to popular belief, yet it is true and the policy of police departments everywhere. Do not be misled by that "protect and serve" logo printed on many police cruisers. I am not bashing the police, they fight the good fight in an impossible and thankless job, but their policy should be known to all. Fight for your second amendment rights, especially you in CA, NY, DC, IL, where they have been so sorely abridged.


Posted By: greenie227 (May 1, 2008 at 8:14 PM)

Zzim, I have to disagree with you -- policemen don't take the job because they want to kill people. Please! Policemen take the job because it's a job. Because they need a job, and their dad was a policemen, or they did well on the exam, or they think it's going to be exciting, or they want to serve the public. Or it's just a job. Unfortunately in the Sean Bell disaster, the policemen got off scot-free (except for perhaps the everlasting guilt of killing a man who didn't deserve it and wondering how that will play out in the afterlife destination). But there is usually a huge investigation when a policeman kills anyone -- it is not taken lightly, and it is not part of the job. Please don't make the situation worse by assuming terrible things about a group of people you don't know. That doesn't help anything. Remember, if you don't want assumptions made about you based on your gender, race or religion, you can't make assumptions about anyone else based on the same -- or occupation.


Posted By: ChrisEZ (May 2, 2008 at 10:59 AM)

As a 40-year old African American man who grew up on the South Side of Chicago, my early experiences with the police were very influential of my opinions today. As a elementary school-aged kid, me and my friends were constantly getting patted down and harangued by (usually white) police officers. At the same time, dice games and drug deals were allowed to take place in the neighborhood park - which the police would not go into unless they were 4 deep. One day as high school let out, four cars came barreling down the street with shotguns being fired in our direction, while the Chicago police office assigned to our school cowered by the door. Believe me, I can go on.

At 13 I was shot by a thug who thought he owned the strip of sidewalk where I was waiting for my friend outside a grocery store. It took three calls to 911 and 30 minutes before help arrived... if you can call 2 unmarked cars, 4 parole cars, and two paddy-wagons help. Because my wound was not life-threatening (other than the mass quantity of blood I was losing) I was taken to the hospital in the paddy-wagon. They never found the guy who shot me.

Now I have an 11 year-old daughter who lives in a relatively quiet suburban community, attends a private Christian school, and could in no way relate to my experiences. I teach her that there is an appropriate response to everything. If you're in a dangerous environment, expect and be prepared for the potential danger. That especially includes coming in contact with people possessing guns - police or otherwise. I teach her that the she is her own best protection, given that the police are reactive and not proactive. As she gets older, we will definitely discuss the merits of those reactions. For now, I’m OK with her believing in the ideal.


Posted By: Guns, Police, Children : Elaine Vigneault (May 9, 2008 at 12:08 PM)

PingBack from http://www.elainevigneault.com/guns-police-children.html