The Root | TheRoot.com
Skip Navigation
Cancel

Blog Title

  •  
Full Post
Posted Friday, May 23, 2008 2:31 PM

The Attacks on Michelle Obama [response]

melissa harrislacewell

Marc,

Angry doesn’t even come close to explaining how this photo makes me feel. This photo terrorizes me. One of my black, female graduate students sent it to me on at 7:00 this morning. It was the first image I saw when I woke up.

Nearly five thousand men and women were lynched in the American South in the years between Reconstruction and the Civil Rights Movement. These black men and women were not slaves. They were hardworking, taxpaying citizens of America who had been granted the right to vote and given equal protection of the law in the American Constitution. Yet they were viciously murdered for tiny infractions of a racist social code. These gruesome murders were carefully constructed to impact the entire community. The lynch mob not only killed its victim, it stripped whole communities of any sense of security, protection, or predictability.

The attacks of September 11 had the same effect on America. As the attacks robbed thousands of families and communities of their loved ones, it also destroyed our country’s sense of security. Like the victims of lynching, the victims of September 11 were targeted solely for their identity, not for any crime. After September 11, African Americans mourned along with the rest of the country. But many black Americans also harbored a secret knowledge that this was not the first time that Americans had faced terrorism.

We remember Emmett Till’s broken body and distorted face. We remember four little girls murdered in a church basement. We remember grandmothers who dared to register to vote being visited in the dead of night by masked white men bearing torches and crosses. We remember slain leaders and know that strange fruit hung from American trees too recently to be discounted as archaic history. While the memory of racial terrorism is fresh for many, it has been completely absent from public conversations about terrorism over the past seven years.

American schools teach children that Jim Crow was about separate water fountains and sitting at the back of city buses. Jim Crow was so much more. The system allowed and encouraged daily acts of terrorism against ordinary, working black people. Sometimes the terrorism took the form of vicious public murders where black men were tortured and maimed before being killed. Other times the terrorism took the form of economic, social, or psychological abuse meted out against African Americans simply to remind them of their subordinate position. For black people there was no protection against the whims of racists protected by a Southern code.

That is the history that crawled up into the bed with me this morning when I clicked this link. That is the history that curled up into the pit of my stomach and made me feel like throwing up. Michelle and the Obama daughters means so much to me as a black woman raising a my own young daughter. That such a horrifying imaging of Michelle could be deployed in her so-called-defense made me sad, angry and really very scared. 

Melissa

You must be a registered user to comment.  Click here to register.  Already a user?  Click here to login.

Member Comments

Posted By: Robin08 (May 23, 2008 at 3:46 PM)

Wow.  I am damn near dumbstruck at every level of this incident.  The imagery in the photo, the fact that it was created presumably by an Obama supporter -- all of it leaves me speechless.  That may be apropos for me in this instance, as the deepest feeling sometimes shows itself in silence.


PingBack from http://jim-crow-laws.info/2008/05/23/the-attacks-on-michelle-obama-response/


Posted By: POLpursun (May 23, 2008 at 6:06 PM)

Right 09/11/2001 was NOT the most grievous act of terrorism on U.S. soil.

Given that last paragraph of yours, Melissa, the likes of the Nat Turners of

the world come to mind.  Makes one wonder how many of them decided to die once

rather than a thousand times.  Then we have ANYONE with the crass arrogance to

question the patriotism of ANY AA who, as they say, works hard and plays by the rules.


PingBack from http://publicmindshare.com/movin6/1969/12/31/the-attacks-on-michelle-obama-response/


Posted By: techieb1 (May 24, 2008 at 12:58 AM)

Fear was not my first response to this demeaning image of Michelle Obama. Anger and then action. I want whoever thought up that offensive message to pay. Shut down the website, write letters to their corporate offices, etc. I am tired of being afraid. I am ready to fight back.


Posted By: whitegirl71 (May 24, 2008 at 9:19 AM)

Horrible.  The loving detail with which this image was created... was the artist fantasizing?  Did the editors think it was funny?  Pointed satire?  Unfortunately, the violent and sexual humiliation of women is part of our present, not just our history.  It's ugly, ugly, ugly.  Let's hope Michelle Obama's children never see this image.


Posted By: rainydaiyz (May 24, 2008 at 11:17 AM)

Melissa, you are skirting around the issue. All of us know the history of lynching in this country, there's no need to wax on about it for four paragraphs. Why didn't you answer Marc's question about how come Barack hasn't done more to shut this down---and how should Barack's camp respond?


Posted By: duboisist (May 25, 2008 at 3:08 PM)

M&M, I totally understand your hurt and confusion.  I experienced something very similar in the 1980s while getting my school to divest from S. A.  Some of people decided to depict capital punishment in South African by hanging effigies of black figures from the balcony of the student union building.  I was offended and I cursed people out in public, but they went on to do more stupid things.

I completely understand that people I’m working with are going to do things I consider stupid.  I don’t assume they are evil, racist, etc. for one simple reason – I CAN NEVER KNOW WHAT IS GOING ON INSIDE ANOTHER PERSON.  If I could know, the only thing I could do about it is commit an act of VIOLENCE and I practice nonviolence.

The people at the Daily Koz and my classmates felt entitled to do what they were doing.   “They” weren’t racists.   Those “other” people were.  They were trying to “enlighten” the people who weren’t as wonderful as they.  They “HAD to do something.”

These children will say their parents are racists and not them.  That’s exactly what my classmates said in the 80s.  That's what their parents said in the 1960s and grandparents said in THE 1860s.

These people watch the Huffington Post, Chris Matthews, and Barak Obama label Hillary Clinton and her supporters “racist” and use it as an excuse to say and do some of the most violent things imaginable.  You can’t explain to them how this is different and they can’t see the difference for themselves, BECAUSE THERE IS NO DIFFERENCE.

If you are going to applaud the sexist treatment of Sen. Clinton because you think “she deserves it,” you should prepare yourself for when your wife, mother, daughter, or you get the same treatment from the same people.  “What goes around comes around.”

I find it much easier to be against it all the time no matter who it is against.


Posted By: Pages tagged "social code" (May 27, 2008 at 4:26 PM)

PingBack from http://www.blogbookmarker.com/tags/social-code


Posted By: Kasha (May 27, 2008 at 6:00 PM)

As i visualize what may have been on the minds of the people who placed the picture on line i am forced to remember how as a Cuban exile who came on a boat to the US shores back in the day.   I am forever reminded of how the media depicted many of us (the Afro Cuban) as criminals, dayum near starved to death, filthy, and disorieitated due to the long ocean trip we had endured.

i still have many pictures taken from the web and after several yrs of living in the belly of this beast i have come to understand that most if not more of the media and others always try to put the worst face on an African possible..However, as someone who has rizen above the BS and painful depiction..i say to you all..They still cannot touch us as a people..and defiantely cannot touch sister Obama..We know the real deal...


Posted By: cancan (May 27, 2008 at 8:45 PM)

I wrote a piece on my blog this past weekend about my reaction to this terrible, violent image.  It's called "Apology Not Accepted."  I'm tired of pundits, politicians, entertainers making racist and misogynistic statements and then apologizing.  (blog.candelariasilva.com)


Posted By: A-Kos-ted « Ms. Ann Drist’s Blog (May 28, 2008 at 7:58 PM)

PingBack from http://msandrist.wordpress.com/2008/05/28/a-kos-ted/


Posted By: faithfulservant3 (May 30, 2008 at 10:28 PM)

I'm more interested in the attacks on Michelle Obama for saying that she is proud of her country for the first time in her adult life.  This isn't unpatriotic, it has to do with growing up and learning the facts.

I can remember watching the Olympics as a child and routing for the USA; and wearing red, white and blue sweat bands on the tennis courts.  But when I started reading more about our history in high school, and got deeper into America's foreign policy in college I was saddened.  Mind you, I had already overlooked riots, assassinations and personal racist slights.

It's not that we hate this country, it's the unspoken injustices and the failure to reach our potential that makes us ashamed of our own country deep down.  We call ourselves godly when we're not.  Fourth of July fireworks and flag waving anyone?


Posted By: JustBecauseIAm (June 2, 2008 at 5:26 PM)

what photo?


Posted By: NanaJackie (June 2, 2008 at 9:34 PM)

I did not see the picture, whatever horrible thing it is. It  can only have influence over those that are already narrow minded. It is these people that we should have the most pity for. I would love for one of them to genetically prove that there is less African in their ancestery than hers. When we all are truely proud of our ideosyncracies  When we fit so comfortably in those things that make each of us unique, then and only then will bigotry lose it's steam.I personally am a grandmother who occassionally jokes about suffering from crs, I also  am an amputee who has no problem telling the Ilene joke, if it helps others see that it's nothing to me, after all I do lean, very gracefully I might add.


Posted By: deemill (June 4, 2008 at 1:23 PM)

Comment: You guys of the liberal leftist media are something. After trashing Hillary because he is a woman and somewhat less liberal than Obama. Now you elevating an inexperienced man to the level of Greek mythology. I bet you if Hillary went to dinner at the so-called Rev. Wright 3 or 4 times, you hyppocrite of the media would trash her even more and call for her resignation. You are something! You sexist media will have the shock of your life when your little creation name Barack Hussein Obama will be sent back to South Chicago where he belongs to reunite with his friend Weathermen leader Bernadine Dohrn and Ayers (terrorists and criminals), RezKo (criminal), his spiritual leaders of 17 to 20 years Farrakhan, Wright and Pfleger (racists and anti-semitic), his racist wife Michelle (review her thesis, listen to her own comments, wait the upcoming tape). So how many pass are you derranged leftist going to give him. Are you guilty for your ancestors racisms? are you you mentally sick with your liberalism? Do you hate America so much by your communism? Do you hate George Bush so much that you are willing to put your ego first? At least george Bush never insulted America! After alll according to you, he stealed the election From Gore by getting elected when Gore won the popular vote. Why are you not outrage when Obama steal the nomination when Hillary won the popular vote? why don't you cry foul play when Obama got awarded with delegates when he removed voluntary his name on the ballot in Michgan? What are you not defending reverse racism and sexism? Your double standard is sickening. But get what? we the real American women and men for that matter, will be getting revenge in November and will send your little fictional creation named Barack Hussein Obama back with the terrorists that he belongs in the South side of Chicago.


Posted By: deemill (June 4, 2008 at 1:23 PM)

Comment: You guys of the liberal leftist media are something. After trashing Hillary because he is a woman and somewhat less liberal than Obama. Now you elevating an inexperienced man to the level of Greek mythology. I bet you if Hillary went to dinner at the so-called Rev. Wright 3 or 4 times, you hyppocrite of the media would trash her even more and call for her resignation. You are something! You sexist media will have the shock of your life when your little creation name Barack Hussein Obama will be sent back to South Chicago where he belongs to reunite with his friend Weathermen leader Bernadine Dohrn and Ayers (terrorists and criminals), RezKo (criminal), his spiritual leaders of 17 to 20 years Farrakhan, Wright and Pfleger (racists and anti-semitic), his racist wife Michelle (review her thesis, listen to her own comments, wait the upcoming tape). So how many pass are you derranged leftist going to give him. Are you guilty for your ancestors racisms? are you you mentally sick with your liberalism? Do you hate America so much by your communism? Do you hate George Bush so much that you are willing to put your ego first? At least george Bush never insulted America! After alll according to you, he stealed the election From Gore by getting elected when Gore won the popular vote. Why are you not outrage when Obama steal the nomination when Hillary won the popular vote? why don't you cry foul play when Obama got awarded with delegates when he removed voluntary his name on the ballot in Michgan? What are you not defending reverse racism and sexism? Your double standard is sickening. But get what? we the real American women and men for that matter, will be getting revenge in November and will send your little fictional creation named Barack Hussein Obama back with the terrorists that he belongs in the South side of Chicago.


Posted By: deemill (June 4, 2008 at 1:27 PM)

For any of you that are not greatful for the opportunities that this great nation have given you, go back to Africa!!!! By the way, Michelle Hussein Obama is an ungreatful  rasist pig who needs to pack her bag to Kenya!!!!


Posted By: NanaJackie (June 5, 2008 at 3:02 PM)

To  deemill. Surely you must have respect for Ted Kennedy, because he has always proven himself to do what is good for all of the citizens of this country. Both parties have the greatest respect and admiration for him. Wouldn't you think that he knows the candidates on a much more personal basis than any of us ever will? Many of the people that have come forward to endorse Senator Obama are undoubtably respected in the eyes of mostly the working class whites. I don't know where you are getting your information, but surely you know there are far too many rediculous theories out there about anyone in the public eye. By the way I am a working class white person.


Posted By: cheesemonkey (June 9, 2008 at 1:25 AM)

This is not a photo. It is a doctored piece of propaganda. Do not mistake this for a photo.


Posted By: warrior dowager (June 11, 2008 at 4:12 PM)

Let's have a word for Reconstruction for a change.  Ihad an ancient great great aunt who lived through Reconstruction.  That was far, far worse on the white people left at home.  .My grandparents married in 1889.  In Georgia, the black troops moved in late 1875.  One of the most

brilliant engieers in Georgia who was  neither pro nor con on the war; he was a genious for

building and repaining machinery.  He was walking home to his  four children and expectant wife

when a Black  Trooper sat in an up stairs  window and said, "I'm going to kill the first white man

who walks up the street."  And he did

Not until well after Roosevelt did the white South begin to be equal in means, in opportunity,

in respect--such as it is even now.

Before the Civil WAr, New England states had threatened to leave the union because of

tarifff and sailing construtions.  

For God's sake quite pissing and moaning because somebody says the wrong word.

You are EQUAL, remember, not hot house flowers who have to be worried over.


Posted By: Buy carisoprodol. (June 15, 2008 at 12:35 PM)

Buy carisoprodol.


Posted By: Zoloft. (July 18, 2008 at 1:56 AM)

Phentermine zoloft.


Posted By: Aldactone hyperkalemia. (July 30, 2008 at 2:29 AM)

Aldactone hirtuism. Kayexalate for hyperkalemia caused by aldactone.


Posted By: Does propecia work. (August 4, 2008 at 3:45 AM)

Propecia. Reversing the effects of propecia. Buy xenical and propecia online from pharmcom. Generic propecia. Propecia uk order online.