The Root | TheRoot.com
Skip Navigation
Cancel

Blog Title

  •  
Full Post
Posted Tuesday, March 18, 2008 8:18 AM

Obama's Response to Wright [Response]

melissa harrislacewell

Marc

 

Put down your remote control and step away from CNN, MSNBC and especially FoxNews. This is not a certified political crisis!  Let's review the issue: six years ago the now retired pastor of a church in Chicago gave a sermon which reflected the views of many people sitting in the pews. Let's call this what it is, a manufactured "scandal" meant to embarrass Barack and chip away at his solid black electoral support and his growing national electoral coalition.

 

It is disgusting, politically motivated and racially ignorant, but it is not a political crisis.  A political crisis is when a government lies to its people and to foreign nations in order to drag them into war. A political crisis is when a government watches thousands of it citizens suffer and starve on national television and doesn't even bother to send water. A political crisis is when a Congress deregulates an industry that then financially rapes consumers and provokes a widespread recession and housing crisis.  A political crisis is when a President knowingly lies to a grand jury and touches off an impeachment proceeding over a personal issue.  

 

I refuse to buy into any Barack bashing on this topic.  I wish we could have a reasoned conversation about race in this country. I wish that we could use the Jeremiah Wright anxiety as a teachable moment to encourage Americans to reflect on how faith, race and patriotism are intertwined.  But you and I have both done enough TV to know that sound bites rarely contribute to a broad and complex public discourse.  That is why TheRoot.com is so great!  We can hammer out the issues here and present complex arguments.  But I think it is somewhat unfair to ask Obama to perform this same function in the middle of an election with a racially tone-deaf audience.  

 

I will say that this whole thing feel familiar in the worst way.  I feel like I am in middle school again having to explain to my white friends why I don't want to go to a pool party. I feel like I am on my first job having to explain to admissions committees the difference between various HBCUs. I feel like many black people feel all the time: burdened by the necessity of having to explain black culture, life, thought and practice to an often hostile and shockingly uninformed white audience.  

 

Yes, I wish Barack could do it for us and keep us from carrying the burden. But in this case I am willing to do it for him.   To support a candidate means to provide him support and help him do things he cannot do.  I will keep doing my best to explain why Jeremiah Wright is a prophetic pastor whom many of of love and support.  Barack: you go get that nomination brother. 

 

Melissa 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

You must be a registered user to comment.  Click here to register.  Already a user?  Click here to login.

Member Comments

Posted By: Mr. Reparations (March 18, 2008 at 10:14 AM)

You know, Melissa - Marc, I hear both of your points.  I too wish there were a dialogue on race.  I applaud this turmoil because it is forcing discussions on race at an exceptionally high level.  To me, this is reparations...repairing a breach by increasing understanding.  I'm waiting with anticipation for Senator Obama's speech, because I was disappointed in the way he cowered under the mainstream pressure.  More of my thoughts are found on my blog: www.reparationsblog.com


Posted By: clareon (March 18, 2008 at 10:26 AM)

Melissa, I just watched you and Marc on CNN with Tony Harris.  You were great.  I am white, a progressive liberal who grew up in a very white suburbs 60s and now living in a very white town in Canada.  As I was listening to the Wright brouhaha growing over the weekend I knew that the discussion was off.  As you said, we don't even have the same language to discuss race.  I agree with you that this is a teachable moment--who knows if the media will allow the discussion to happen.  I hope Senator Obama has the courage to talk about the deeper issues and not kowtow to the narrow viewpoint of the mainstream press.


Posted By: helys (March 18, 2008 at 11:54 AM)

I am wondering what Obama will say today. I support him for president precisely because he does understand the views of Jeremiah Wright and also understands what it takes to succeed in United States politics. Hillary and MCCain care nothing for Black people, people -- or any low income people really. They don't have to try to be the missing piece between the two americas.  

Mainstream America does not understand Black anger or pain. How's a politician to be that bridge while trying to get in a position to make the change.

The clinton machine will do anything to get this nomination and the battle is only adding to McCain's support. America needs Obama in the presidency. I believe Black folks,  white folks  brown red whatever color we need Obama in the presidency--- even though he won't say everything you want him to say. What he will say and do will be enough to start a major power shift. He can't do it all at once or by himself. He wouldn't be a candidate right now if he was saying what Wright says. Would that be good for African Americans, I think not.

I hope he comes out with a speech that takes us forward.


Posted By: preach1 (March 18, 2008 at 2:13 PM)

As a black Baptist pastor and a seminary professor I strongly believe that more needs to be said about the black prophetic preaching tradition wwithin which Jeremiah Wright operates. Barack Obama is not the person who should be expected to do that; progressive black pastors and scholars of religion must assume that role and responsibility. Someone must state that within one strand of the black preaching tradition the sovereignty of God always trumps the separation of church and state, and "God bless America" is always trumped by "He's Got the Whole World in His Hands."  Marvin McMickle, Ph.D.  Cleveland, OH


Posted By: selainet (March 18, 2008 at 4:20 PM)

"But you and I have both done enough TV to know that sound bites rarely contribute to a broad and complex public discourse. . . .But I think it is somewhat unfair to ask Obama to perform this same function in the middle of an election with a racially tone-deaf audience. "

Turns out, Melissa, you underestimated him.


Posted By: Laureate (March 18, 2008 at 5:31 PM)

I saw you on CNN today--all loud and interrupting.


Posted By: truthseeker (March 18, 2008 at 5:53 PM)

"Let's call this what it is, a manufactured "scandal"" Melissa

All I got to say is "Let the church say YEEEEESSSSSSSS, YESSSSSSSSSSS, YEEEESSSSSSSS


Posted By: dw314 (March 18, 2008 at 9:08 PM)

What are you babbling about? Obama got busted. He used Wrights church to get ahead politically and he didn't dare call this man out because he would have lost the support of this big church Now, it's coming back to bite him. If he didn't  know this man was a problem why did he uninvite him to his announcing he was running for president? A different kind of politics my butt. Obama has been hiding behind his race since he started. Anytime he's criticized he plays the race card and swears it's his critics who are doing. He has managed to make the Clintons of all people out to be racists. He will lose if he gets the nomination and I bet that's the last time a black gets this far for awhile. The next person of color to get the nod will be hispanic I guarantee you that. His whining about Mrs Clinton and how she should get out of the race is just becoming boring and I believe this latest broohaha is only the beginning of his end. We better stop voting for him because he's one of us and get behind Hillary now. She's the better person to fight Mccain.


Posted By: ookama343 (March 18, 2008 at 10:15 PM)

melissa, one word describes you and barack obama... HYPOCRITE! stop spinning this, stop being an apologist and stop acting as he if still can do no wrong. you do not sell-out your friends to purchase the favor of your enemies. his speech was too little too late, as he should have utilized sotbu to address racial issues and his own policies before the media forced his hand and pulled his card (no pun intended). his arrogance has been stymied by humility. he is disappointing as he denigrates the memory of our martyrs and freedom-fighters, because he is still pandering, plain and simple. his conciliatory speech does not begin to patch up his patent disregard for American Blacks and our traditions of which he is a neophyte. for mr. obama... the chickens have come home to roost.


Posted By: Kinsmankid (March 19, 2008 at 1:06 PM)

Your editorial regarding Rev. Wright earlier this week was wonderful.  One of my church members was on the verge of tears after reading it.  I think Obama did a good job in talking about his relationship with Wright yesterday.  I, like Marc, wished he had expressed this when he was first approached by the media regarding Wright.  He made his pastor come across like a nutcase, which made Obama seem foolish in the process.  Why would anyone go to a church of 20 years if he felt the preacher was like a "crazy uncle?"  Apparently, Trinity UCC does a lot in the Greater Chicago community through programs initiated by Wright.  Why couldn't his focus had been on that?  I'm still a supporter of Obama and hope -- make that pray -- that this incident doesn't hurt his chances to be elected.  I really enjoy the debates between you and Marc.  I usually agree with Marc's comments about Obama, but this time I think is was a little too harsh.  


Posted By: Jacksoniandem73 (March 19, 2008 at 5:26 PM)

The pile as it became to beknown at ground zero was still smoldering when rev wright gave that "sermon" 7 yrs ago.... my friends body was in that pile, and this piece of *** "reverend" blames us. Not a particular admnistartion, but the whole country. When you address America, you address all Americans. Very troubling to this bi racial male, who has faced serious dioscrimination from both sides, try growing up in an Irish 'hood being half PR, half Italian, but then according to rev wright the romans were the first whites to abuse blacks, and this guy is considered one of the top black pastors in AMerica?? I'm in the wrong business


Posted By: misscleo (March 19, 2008 at 11:40 PM)

As I pondered the issues raised by the Wright flap and the self-critical crisis it must have prompted in Barack, my thoughts turned many times to another prophetic preacher, who by coincidence (not) was part of the United Church of Christ.  I had the pleasure of hearing Coffin when I was a student at Andover and when I was at Yale, but did not know the measure of the man at that time.  At my college reunion a couple of years ago about a month after Rev. Coffin's death, I bought his Letters to a Young Doubter.  In considering the message of Rev. Wright, even in those isolated morsels, I consider the words of Rev. Coffin quoted in his obituary from April 2006:

"Patriotism at the expense of another nation is as wicked as racism at the expense of another race," he declared, adding: "Let us resolve to be patriots always, nationalists never. Let us love our country, but pledge allegiance to the earth and to the flora and fauna and human life that it supports — one planet indivisible, with clean air, soil and water; with liberty, justice and peace for all."

http://www.nytimes.com/2006/04/13/us/13coffin.html?pagewanted=4&_r=1

He also said, "Let us recognized the fundamental, unacceptability about unpleasant truth."


Posted By: sanlain (March 20, 2008 at 8:24 AM)

Some are agast and angry that Rev. Wright would say God damn America rather than God Bless America.  Look at it from where the majority of African Americans look at it from.  Barack Obama is a very unique and fortunate African American because he knows who his father is and he knows who his ancestors are (personally)  He knows who he is!   The majority of African America does not know these things, because it was stolen from us.  We carry the names of our slave owners not of our forefathers.  So we cannot go to what ever part of Africa we came from to look up our long lost ancestors because WE DON'T KNOW OUR NAME.    Barack knows his name and he knows his ancestors on both sides of his family.  So when one looks at and doesn't understand deep seeded black anger , look at it in the full context .

The Root.com is an avenue for tracing our roots and for finding out where we may have originated, but we still don't have a name.  That was stolen from us.  


Posted By: truthserum (March 20, 2008 at 11:59 AM)

For those of us that support Barack we can only control what we do. If we do what we should be doing in this historic moment in history Barack Obama will win the Democratic nomination. From that point on white america will determine if he will be our next president. If we as African Americans register and vote in unprecedented numbers( with enough white support) he can win states like Virginia, Mississippi, Misouri, and Pennsylvania. Statiscally nearly 50% of eligible voters don't cast their vote. If we work to register and get these people via absentee or otherwise to come out and vote HE CAN WIN. WE CAN WIN.


Posted By: mikepanula (March 21, 2008 at 9:57 AM)

SO the pastor was misunderstood, justified or just plain misquoted

We have suffered.  We have been discriminated against.  We have all the odds against us.  We are never heard.  We have the right to anger, hate, mistrust, poor judgement and self-pity.  Our past has earned this for us.

Future?  Who he?  Did he call AGAIN?  Tell him we're not taking his damn calls.


Posted By: Realtimeviewer (March 24, 2008 at 6:24 PM)

Melissa Lacewell,

Last Friday I went to see Realtime with Bill Maher.  Let me say I was disappointed that you were one of his guests.  You are a closed minded pompous racist.  You should thank God he let you on his show.  Once people see what you are all about, I hope you lose your tenure at Princeton.


Posted By: lamesabassman (March 24, 2008 at 10:57 PM)

Reality 101.... when the turtle starts to distance the hare..... then turtle soup is on the menu.... and tell

me.... who didnt see this coming.....  here in Cali.... we have this issue.... Native American Casinos....

on one hand.... a positive move for them so they are be helpful to themselves and others.....

nobody ever paid them a never-mind..... until ... one day when a group from the Nations went to Wall St. to ask one simple question...... just how do you start a Bank...... well.... it was like the '20/'30 when

no one thought to bother with the pennies that were passed around betting on the Numbers gig up in

Harlem, NYC .... 'til someone started to count those pennies.... then ... all hell broke loose in Harlem  and other places in this country.... and the Numbers gig was taken over from the ones who started it in the first place....

the same with Obama's gig.... can a person... who does'nt look like the powers that be.... be thought of as a prospect to be a President of these United States.... and after you wrap your brain

around that ... dig this... while the whole world is watching the way we do business here in America

will we turn it all around to make the Dream come alive.... in our lifetime..... or like our deficit... leave

that legacy to our progeny to deal with..... we as a people.... as a country.... should not stand by

for the same Dog and Pony show ..... ever again...... can we all just get along... or get it right for

once.... yeah... Rome wasnt built in a day.... but dang.... it's 250 years..... when will all the others

.... who have come to these shores... or have been born FIRST here... get a shot at the Brass Ring

instead of being shot down..... or shot at....

lamesabassman...... just a thought ..... while waiting for a latte' at Starbucks.....


Posted By: RRCHAL (March 27, 2008 at 8:29 PM)

Great job tonight on teh McNeil/Lehrer News Hour!


Posted By: Ultracet. (June 15, 2008 at 4:17 AM)

Ultracet pregnancy. Lexapro-ultracet-interactions. Ultracet.


Posted By: Ultram. (June 20, 2008 at 8:32 PM)

Ultram. Information on ultram er.


Posted By: Buy didrex. (July 30, 2008 at 7:30 AM)

Didrex information from drugs com. Re buy didrex.