The Root | TheRoot.com
Skip Navigation
Cancel

Blog Title

Full Post
Posted Friday, March 28, 2008 9:57 AM

REVERSE STEREOTYPES

Keith Josef Adkins

A film company once asked me to look at an urban novel and see if I could create a TV series from it.  I won't reveal the title or author [some may say plagiarist] but I will say the word "Ghetto" was printed across the cover page.  Now I was a snob when it came to literature.  If it wasn't Morrison, Marquez, Joyce, or Dumas [and I mean Henry, not Alexandre] you couldn't offer me a kidney to read that garbage.  

Well, opportunity knocked.  And suddenly my snobby-self was reading nook and cranny of a certain premiere urban writer.  Some would call me a hypocrite.  You know, one minute turning up my nose, and then the next, my nose all in it.  But I would call it trying to maintain a solid checking account.  Anyway, I was given about two weeks to read, decipher and decide.  It took me a week.  And although at times the story was difficult to filter with all the b*tches, n*gg*s and other whatnot, it wasn't that bad of story.  It was actually good.  No, I'm lying.  It was horrible.  However, I was able to crank out an outline to a pilot episode, add some flavor to the characters and some necessary heat to the plot.  Next thing I knew I received a call from the film company that the urban writer wanted to meet me.  I was told, she really liked it.

So the day had arrived for us to meet.  The film company's creative exec, the urban queen and myself were to lunch it at one of Beverly Hill's finest.  A brother was cool with a nice little Tapas spot over in Los Feliz, where the vibe was chill and somewhat Bohemian, but Beverly Hills, I was told, was the choice of the urban scribe.  So I didn't argue 'cause bruh wasn't footing the bill.

I walked in five minutes late.  And as I approached the table I saw one smiling face and another perplexed one. Curious, congenial, sexy even, but definitely perplexed.

I sat down, ordered a plate of something seared and something fresh with mint and jumped right in.  Studios, scheduling and possible actors—Mos Def, Cuba Gooding's brother [Omar], Terence Howard even. I nodded and smiled because I hadn't signed a contract at that point, or received one dime.  But the ghetto bard assured me: "This sh*t was gonna make bank!" 

Then the creative director excused herself to the bathroom [too much of something fresh with mint] and that's when the trip TRIPPED out.

"I thought you were a white man."  She said this loud.  And she wasn't trying to be funny either.  She meant it.  Now according to my DNA I'm about 25 percent Euro, but there's nothing about me that looks white.  I'm brown and I've always been brown.

So I asked:  "Why would you think that?

And she said in all seriousness, "All those big words.  All fancy and well-written.  I thought they had hired a white man to develop this sh*t."  And then she laughed.  Not because the joke was on me, but because the joke was on her.  She was expecting a white man to come walking through the door and order his plate of something seared and discuss urban lit on TV.  Oh, I may have forgotten to mention:  this ghetto scribe was African-American.

The meeting ended well, according to her.   I was told she was going to contact Mos Def herself.  That she was going to make sure I was PAID.  That she believed in taking people to the top, that I'll be driving an Escalade. 

After she pulled off in her rented Bentley, I never heard from her again.

I wasn't upset.  One door closes, the other opens.  And I certainly was humbled by having to possibly depend on something I abhorred to help make ends meet.  But what was interesting, of course, was her assumption anything written well or done with confidence and conviction lacks black.  I certainly laughed about her comment with friends. We joked about how ridiculous and funny.  But when I lay in my bed that night, I felt a bit of sadness, maybe even anger.

It's no secret most humans are dodging or defending stereotypes on a daily.  Sometimes I think we're so hyper-aware of the outlandish depictions we look for them when there not even there. In screen and film, if a overweight woman is cast people call her  a "mammy", if a lighter-skinned person is cast, they're accused of being the witch or the savior, if a large man grins next to a Brazilian model, he looks like Kong.  If a writer writes with authority, he couldn't be black at all. 

It's funny and crazy. 

You must be a registered user to comment.  Click here to register.  Already a user?  Click here to login.

Member Comments

Posted By: gardenwzl (March 28, 2008 at 6:01 PM)

Yes, the reverse stereotype sucks.  As a kid, it was being called a "white wannabe" for making the honor roll semester after semester.  It was "why are you talking white?" for speaking with proper grammar.  It was "sounding white" when I answered the phone - so much that a friend of my aunt's hung up on me repeatedly, as she thought she had a wrong number - "I couldn't understand why a white lady kept answering the phone."

Fortunately, these experiences have become less commonplace as I've gone through college and entered the workforce, but really, sadly - my Black world has shrunk.  (I attended a PWI and work with only a small number of folks who look like me.)  I think the only thing we can do is ask those who offer these stereotyper "Why don't you equate quality / education / positive attributes with Blackness?  I think that's pretty sad that you can't see our worth."

Keepin' hope alive for that one.


Posted By: hopiechan (March 29, 2008 at 11:44 PM)

It is truly funny and crazy. I regularly experience something similar. I possess a skill set and knowledge base that only a select few possess. I command a fair price for such. I am met with myriad reactions from potential clients and employees of current clients - mostly, "Are you the new secretary?" I confess that I have not evolved. I still get angry. A friend who is a Black  attorney in a similar position told me once that I expect it to make sense and it won't. Again, I still get angry, because I expect logic to prevail. It doesn't. Now, it feels just crazy.


Posted By: Nuriddeen (March 30, 2008 at 7:08 PM)

It is amusing, sad and frustrating. Their is countless examples of well educated black even during slavery HELLO Philis Weatley! And countless examples of blacvk scholars now. But you keep going brother. It's weird some stereotypes are more true to people than the actual truth. I honestly think those books will soon be done with people are getting bored with the same ol crap. And I love books lie Flyy Girl and Coldest Winter Ever but it was a hood story with integrity. Besides you cannot expect to be sucessful by tellin the same empty stories of drugs, sex, and violence. Unfortunaely these books and hip hop have gone throug this formulaic process. But I sense a writing revolution soon to come.


Posted By: knows2much (March 31, 2008 at 12:38 AM)

"If a overweight woman is cast people call her  a "mammy", if a lighter-skinned person is cast, they're accused of being the witch or the savior, if a large man grins next to a Brazilian model, he looks like Kong.  If a writer writes with authority, he couldn't be black at all. ..."

A slight overstatement, but I understand where you're coming from.


Posted By: ken (March 31, 2008 at 4:53 PM)

I definitely identify with your feelings of sadness and anger over that situation, apparently you're not the only one having this experience.


Posted By: deduction (April 1, 2008 at 11:06 AM)

of course he's not the only one.  are you people surprised that the ignorant exist?  that they are legion?  the world still thinks more good times than cosby show when it comes to the african american experience.  and the worst prejudice can often be found within the community.  as a couple of you stated, this has been around for a long while.  we experienced it as kids growing up and even going back to slave days- there was a definite disconnect between "house slaves" who received education and "field slaves".  

It is sad that people tacitly live and breathe that mentality in 2008.  but some folks just don't want to change their mentality.  they are too busy being victims or being angry or just being.  but there are plenty of folks that buck the mold and plenty of us that realize that the AA experience isn't something that is easy to define, that it encompasses many different walks of life.  

back in my grandma's day, in her community it was all about trying to better yourself.  sure, some people went overboard in trying to "be white", but in general, it was more about being better educated, being able to better take care of your family, and above all, about having class and dignity.  it didn't matter if you lived in the projects, you still handled yourself a certain way.  people had manners.  the same is nowhere near universally true today.  

i don't see any real solution, but to continue on living and showing that not all people are alike- whether they share a common skin color or heritage.  


Posted By: ken (April 1, 2008 at 1:16 PM)

@deduction

I guess I am surprised that this kind of black-on-black racism is so widespread.  Like the author and other commenters here, I heard these taunts about sounding "too white" or whatever during my childhood too.  It was (and still sometimes is) intensely painful to be ostracized by other blacks for crime of simply being myself.


Posted By: pixieopower (April 3, 2008 at 11:44 PM)

I work at a "multicultural" breakfast resturant. But because i was the only white kid i had ever seen until i was 9 i had NO IDEA i was supposed to be racist... until i moved to a scarey little town in Iowa. Now though, the African-american co-workers laugh at me because i REFUSE to trreat them any different than the little blondie high schoolers. Stupid i cant deal with well but racial identity is something that doesnt even phase me. Heck, i am learning 2 different languages just so i can better relate to my co-workers. ((never ask what 'triffing" is when the woman is mad at you......))


Posted By: EscortInMichigan (July 19, 2008 at 12:13 AM)

Oh comne on.   I know you are a self professed snob.  Nothing wrong with that, some of my best friends are snobs. :)   But seriously, "reverse discrimination"?

This is a load of crap. What you have described is no more reverse discrimination than when a white person is discriminated against f(or being white) is "reverse discrimination".  

What you (and whites who are discriminated against) describe is nothing more than discrimination.  That you (and them) feel a need to mistakenly describe it as "reverse discrimination" only speaks to snobbishness, acknowledged or not, that someone like "you" can't/shouldn't be discriminated against like those you view as beneath you.    

There was nothing "reverse" about it.


Posted By: chrissy (July 31, 2008 at 5:11 PM)

ha, funny story and comments. i myself have always been accused of "talking white", "acting white" heck, even "being white". my favorite is "oreo". when people tell me that i jockingly respond : double stuffed! honestly, i could care less. but seriously though, i have never been exposed to people's distorted expectations has much as i have been this summer. i am an intern at a health institute. yesterday i  met with people wanting to discuss their experiences in the field of malaria research, as that is what i would like to go into. one of the people i met seemed very perplexed by the fact that i was black. the only black people in that building were the security guards. it was very sad. he could not even greet me properly. but i just see all these things and laugh about them. i love breaking stereotypes. it's what i've been doing and will continue to do.