The Root | TheRoot.com
Skip Navigation
Cancel

Blog Title

Full Post
Posted Monday, March 24, 2008 6:59 AM

An Open Letter to Tyler Perry

Keith Josef Adkins

Well, you've done it again.  You've managed to pump out another Perry box office triumph.  Two in one year is beyond commendable.  It's a testament to your non-stop industriousness.  And that's not a sardonic stab, that's "truly meant". And your fans, man o man... scurrying the streets like it's raining gold.  I mean, you can hear them laughing from the AMC Theater in Brooklyn to the Magic Johnson Theaters on Crenshaw.  That's pretty amazing and I'd be a fool to mock it.

But I don't want to waste a lot of time offering props for your commitment to bring the black community the moral correction you believe it needs:  a barrage of high-school drop outs, teen pregnancy, deadbeat dads, single moms, infidelity within our bourgeoisie, climate change, unhealthy eating, diabetes, prostate cancer, obesity, AIDS, homophobia, whew... let me not get ahead of myself.  Some of these are my concerns, not yours.  Point is, there's a lot to correct and you have found resolution with humor and parable often found at a Sunday church program or the smoky venues of Moms Mabley, or Stepin Fetchit.  I can't decide which.  And that's not a sardonic stab, that's "truly meant". 

Now I know you're not perfect and there's only so much a cultural custodian can clean up in one decade, but why?  And with that I mean why THIS way?  Do you believe black people are only open to moral restructuring if they see themselves outrageously [and some would claim buffoonishly] caricatured?  You know, in order for their souls to be softened and readied for change?  Do you believe black people have been historically dehumanized so much so that self-deprecating and communal degradation has become commonplace and has been infused into certain types of entertainment?  What DO you believe?

You will most likely never hear from me after this. Trust me.  And you certainly don't need my support or criticism.  You have plenty to last a lifetime, I'm sure you know.  But I am curious if you ever think about these things.  Or if you're simply an entertainer with a moral mission to deliver by any laugh necessary.  Or... and I'm serious about this:  do you gloat that we dissenters [or believers] are way off the mark?  That, in fact, you have a strategy?  That for three years you inundate the community with buffoonish examples of their morally ambiguous lives until they become so exhausted by the glare that they demand a refund, THEN you unleash your Kong?  A witty, intelligent look at black life where your audience doesn't get license to laugh in the aisles at someone's oversized breasts, but to take a good look at life without clownish coddling.  Is that it?  You will offer something so profound [and witty] it will leap them into the three-dimension?  Where they belong?

And that's not a sardonic stab, that's "truly meant".


You must be a registered user to comment.  Click here to register.  Already a user?  Click here to login.

Member Comments

Posted By: nola_diva (March 24, 2008 at 4:03 PM)

Finally!  Another person who feels the same way about the Tyler Perry machine as I do.  I agree so much with this commentary.  And did you realize that in almost all of his movies the 'bad guy' is the 'dark-skinned' brother and the 'chivalrous good brother is the light-skinned one?  Go back and look!  Think...shemar moore, rick fox, etc.,.  I HATE these buffoonish plays and movies that many of our supposedly talented brothers and sisters create.  Can't we have a morality play without the big loud talking hands on hip black woman, or the church-going, lord 'a mercy crying woman, or the cat-daddy cad, or the low self-esteem woman who just needs to meet the right man in order to get right?  GMAMFB!!!!


Posted By: ken (March 25, 2008 at 9:23 AM)

Damn son!  I haven't seen any of Tyler Perry's movies and I doubt I ever will, but the fact of the matter is that lots of Black folks love his flicks.  These are the same people who kept "The Parkers" on for five seasons and many other shows that show Black people to be buffoonish stereotypes.  The real questions isn't why is Perry making these movies, it's why are people still paying money to see them?


Posted By: GirlinDC (March 25, 2008 at 10:15 AM)

I have seen all of the Tyler Perry movies and one theme that is really beginning to get on my nerves is how he allows the star of each film to meet and fall in love with the perfect man---every single time. It's simply unrealistic.  I know they're just movies, but Tyler is the one going around telling everyone who will listen that he is in the business of telling "our stories". Well for his latest film, "Meet the Browns", Angela Bassett is portraying a woman so poor that she can barely put food on the table.  I'm just waiting for someone else to notice the fact that she's wearing designer jeans and shoes thoughout the film! I thought he did a great job with "Why did I get married".  Now, it seems like he's gone back to his old bag of empty tricks.    


Posted By: jstrick (March 25, 2008 at 10:44 AM)

Yeah, I constantly ask why as far as Tyler Perry is concerned. Will he ever really make something better? My thing is I wouldn't mind his movies if people took them as jokes, but no you talk to alot of folks about his movies and/or plays and they act like you are insulting God himself by not liking his form of entertainment.


Posted By: Randomness… « Tallulah Bankhead (March 25, 2008 at 11:36 AM)

PingBack from http://tallulahbankhead.wordpress.com/2008/03/25/randomness/


Posted By: Phillyfilm (March 25, 2008 at 12:07 PM)

I'm not gonna lie to you I don't enjoy Tyler Perry's movies that much.  But I do respect him a lot. I'm not ready to throw the baby out with the bath water.   I'm not about to dismiss the fans of this man as an uneducated masses.  Not saying that is what you were doing but it can come across that way. His fans make up the diaspora of the community from the top crust to the hood.  It's a good time for the family because people feel like they can relate to the people on the screen good or bad.  So instead of bashing what he has made how bout we think about why the community seems so into what he makes.

If we are gonna knock Perry than we gotta knock Ice Cube for the same thing.  However I'm not.   Let these brothas work the system and build up their Hollywood financial props.  They will make better projects eventually.  Neither one of them started off as filmmakers or producers.   They have to make some things in order to make the things they wanna make.   I can't wait to see a Tyler Perry film with nothing but strong actors in it not just one great actor like Angela Basset and then Rick Fox or Janet Jackson in the film.   I don't understand why he casts the way he does.  Maybe he thinks he uses people like Janet for marketing purposes.  I hope he understands that the community is coming out for him and his play history not necessarily the people in the films.  He just needs to make sure he has the most talented people on the screen and not a bunch of singers and celebrities.

This guy is not Spike Lee or Martin Scorsese.  He is a writer and a somewhat talented comedic actor.   His plays were really one man shows with a church choir behind them.  He is turning very simple plays into movies.  The problem with Black cinema and TV is that we are not diverse enough.  Don't hate the Wayans like the NAACP did because they are comics.  Look for the new talent like myself who are trying to think outside the box of what we often see.  Sometimes producers can only get money for Black comedy films.

I respect and feel a lot of what you said then I saw that you liked that garbage remake of one of my favorite plays/movies A Raisin in the Sun.  I can't knock Puffy for having the money and opportunity to do what he did but, to say it was good makes me reconsider your opinions on Tyler Perry.  A Raisin in the Sun was held together by Philicia Rashad's wonderful performance.  Other than that I couldn't watch it.  I didn't believe Sean Combs, Diddy, or Puffy at all.


Posted By: library (March 25, 2008 at 1:36 PM)

As a writer, I am so in tune with this letter to Tyler. I am working on a serious of babyboomeresque plays that seek to elevate, educate and resonate, first and for most. Entertainment is tertiary, not the main draw for a legit cathartic experience. I was at the National Black Theater festival in the early years when the mistral shows of the chitilin' circuit were being trashed. A wise Howard University professor made the point that this is what the public wants…. But I sense that they are growing a bit weary of the canned effect…But I wanna go a little deeper and be more thought provoking. I’m not a Howard University professor, but I’ve got a good sense that this is what a lot of people want as well.


Posted By: lovedoristwo (March 25, 2008 at 4:24 PM)

African Americans - you so called highly educated people with professional jobs - when you don't agree with something you always try to bring it down - if you want to trash something trash why don't you trash Friends, Jerry Singfield, movies like Wedding Crasher.  No you rather take a brother down because he's not during it the way you like - why don't you go out and make something better and see how hollywood let's you in - people that go to Tylers movie have seen his plays and they know what to expect - he's not doing anything that is not in the community - take your nose out of white city and visit the community - better yet check out your family history and see if he's not talking about you.  - Doris, New Jersey


Posted By: littlestate (March 25, 2008 at 8:56 PM)

Movies and plays, whether written by Tyler Perry, Martin Scorcese, or Clint Eastwood are meant to entertain.  Now, if Mr. Perry presented his productions as true biographies ,representative of all African American families, I would be upset; however as the plays and movies have been presented ,their main goal is entertainment.  These productions are  relateable to people of all cultures, ages, and classes.  Some of the characters in Mr. Perry's productions, I could replace with relatives and or family friends, others I meet for the first time.   It seems that he is presenting his version of social justice ,and if one doesn't want to see it, then don't buy the ticket.  I myself have watched Happy Gilmore and Waterbory many times, yet I don't think Adam Sandler acting like he is not so smart demands an editorial be written about how socially irresponsible his movies are because they don't require a lot of analytical brain power to watch and enjoy.


Posted By: areynolds (March 26, 2008 at 12:07 PM)

Why not THIS way?  I am a mental health counselor and one of the first things we learn is to meet the clients WHERE THEY ARE!  Successful ministers have learned this as well.  Talk over your listeners' heads or use language and examples they can't relate to and you lose them so they never here your message anyway.  Some of us need the characters Tyler Perry has gifted us with to HEAR the message because these are the people we interact with everyday.  Tyler Perry is smart enough to know he has to use the familiar to GET to the profound.  If you don't like the medium Tyler Perry uses or if you think there is a better way to get the message across then do so.  Don't tear down what works for Tyler and his fans.  If you don't like it, don't support it.  Black folks have long laughed to keep from crying.  Laughter is God's nautural healer.  Don't leave the Souls of Black Folk floundering in the dark by trying to take that away.  We all have a voice.  There is no RIGHT or WRONG way to tell our story.


Posted By: hueami (March 27, 2008 at 4:49 PM)

My borther, I thank you.  If you think the movies are awful, have you just once looked at 2 episodes of House of Payne.  You will gag and his supporters on the website will make you understand why he's able to take their money and give them garbage.  They are some of the most gullible people I've encountered.  I love your honesty about the travesty that is the Tyler Perry Buffoonery Machine.


Posted By: mimundo (March 28, 2008 at 9:39 PM)

It's comedy! Even in the satire Tyler does attempt to weave in some truth. What I appreciate most about his movies and sitcom is his attempt to show African American men as responsible human beings. That part for me is refreshing. I'm sick of hearing and seeing negative images of our men. The men in my family are harding working, caring and responsible husband's and father's. Are they perfect? No. But I don't know anyone that is. Furthermore, I thought Tyler's insightfulness in the move Why did I get Married? was amazing for someone that has never married. The 80/20 rule is right on point. Don't forget that rule if you plan to marry.


Posted By: knows2much (March 31, 2008 at 12:49 AM)

Well, I'm a well educated, articulate professional who LOVES MADEA!!!  There.  I said it.  She is a hilarious character and my biggest gripe about Perry movies is that they contain too much sermonizing and side story and TOO LITTLE MADEA.  

Mr. Adkins, I looked you up on IMDB and was pleased to see that you've written for "Girlfriends," another one of my favorites.  But lets not get lost in space here, there are people who criticize that show for creating stereotypes as well.


Posted By: dr spaceman (April 2, 2008 at 3:06 PM)

Keith,

I agree with you about the Perry movies but, that said, we need to just face facts: humor, or "sense of humor," is so very culturally specific. Apparently, the MAJORITY of black people have a sort or crass sense of humor.  I have learned to accept that fact, as a black man, without feeling embarassed by the fact, and without feeling like I need to castigate black folk who like simple comedy.

I accept that I am in the comedic minority among my own people, since I have NEVER seen one single episode of Moesha, House of Payne, Flavor of Love, Girlfriends, Soul Food, One on One, the Jamie Foxx show... basically, anything that ever appeared on Fox or the WB.

None of my immediate family understands what I ever found funny about Seinfeld, Curb Your Enthusiasm, The Office, Extras, etc. They treat me as if I am the one watching a bunch of Tyler Perry-esque bullshit. I find it kind of amusing, actually.

We don't get British humor, but the Brits do. Ever watch the comedy shows on Univision or Telemundo? Those comedies make TP look like Shakespeare. Are some spanish folk embarassed by their people generally childish sense of humor? Probably.

It is what it is.


PingBack from http://tallulahbankhead.wordpress.com/2008/04/08/a-brief-lesson-on-hollywood-bankability/


Posted By: prefacedey (April 9, 2008 at 12:17 PM)

Well-- I concur somewhat.  Although, I love the dinner table scene in "Why did I get...?"  Tyler you have great gifts-- now that you have practiced them--slow down and polish them.  I am doing that same thing.  I know how difficult it can be attempting to work creatively in this arena.  Keep your soul by building up (rightly) other people.   You actually have a great opportunity now-- to set some cultural arts standards.  I have tried to follow the fruit to the root and work outward.  Not that you have not-- but I am tired of my 14 year-old quoting some of the more sticky lines in your movies.  They don't do much for him.  While you're at it maybe you can plug my book/journal in your next flick.  No, just kidding--unless you just can't help yourself.  ISBN: 1419679252.  "It Really Is All About You--At First" No that was not a shameful plug but bold and beautiful.  It is my Genesis 10 Ministry.  Some of our self-hate and shame can be worked out with my (self-discovery) journal.  Folks just have to get to know themselves to get over themselves and be.  Start somewhere please.  MUCH LOVE TO ALL!


Posted By: stargazr (April 22, 2008 at 5:46 PM)

My biggest problem w/Tyler Perry is his attempt to address situations in which women find themselves in abusive relationships.  He fails miserably in the regard time and time again with the same 'knight in shinning armor' ending. His stories make women out to be helpless victims who have zero responsibility for their own happiness, but who must simply hold out until they find the perfect man to come along and make their world okay.  It's total nonsense and it is this very thinking that directs women towards abusive relationships in the first place! Though I also agree w/many of the comments about the constant parade of stereotypical characters we've all seen time and time again....WHERE is the variety, reflections of the rich tapestry of black life? I know it is hard to get these kinds of films about us into the mainstream...but there are those out there who continue to try, despite the struggle....and THOSE are the folks we should not forget to celebrate.


Posted By: lairdlord (May 20, 2008 at 12:01 AM)

I must be totally honest. I hate "Tyler Perrys" movies and I would rather watch porn before I saturate my mind with that loathsome moralistic , churchified, greasy fried chicken, dramaturgy. What a dumbing down of the "African- American Arts tradition" Oh yeah, those white execs know how to get a black boy to fetch for them. Perry, Jakes, and the rest of those prosperity pimps knew they had a winner by catering to the bible thumping , son and daughters of the faith. What a slap in the face to struggling black artist with something real to express but they ain't hooked up to the gospel train and the execs only respect collaborators who can step and fetch it.  Tyler is your modern day parasite because he's sucking the intelligence and creativity from black people and in it's place giving them a big slice of mediocrity. Amen